• On MovieTome: See the TRAILER for TERMINATOR 4!
July 1, 2008 12:23 PM PDT

Top tech and no cell phone?

Poor little cell phones

(Credit: Kent German/CNET Networks)

It's always a good day at our house when the latest issue of Entertainment Weekly arrives in the mailbox. And when last week's summer double issue arrived, an already good day was made even better. I love top 10 lists, but Entertainment Weekly managed to maximize my pleasure with an entire issue dedicated to "Celebrating the new classics: The 1,000 best movies, TV shows, albums, books, and more of the past 25 years."

Though it started out as a good read the last article forced me to put down the magazine in disgust--I even made it past Die Hard earning ninth place in the top 100 best films from 1983 to 2008. In the list of "The 25 gadgets and innovations with the biggest effect on pop culture since 1983" I was aghast to find the cell phone nowhere on the list. How could a gadget that revolutionized Hollywood business deals, spawned a celebrity accessory culture and served as the main plot device in such cinematic achievements as Cellular get beaten out by the likes of the Amazon Kindle and stadium multiplex seating? To me, it's completely unfathomable. Of course, the iPod and TiVo landed in the top five (how could TiVo not make it?) but satellite radio hardly deserves its ninth-place ranking. Here's the tech that made the top ten.

  1. The DVD player
  2. Napster
  3. TiVo
  4. iPod
  5. YouTube
  6. Realistic CG characters
  7. Digital video cameras for consumers
  8. Flat panel TVs
  9. Satellite radio stations
  10. Stadium multiplex seating

The iPod's 2001 introduction also earned top honors in a readers' poll on the top pop culture moment of the last 25 years. It managed to knock out Michael Jackson's "Thriller" video, Kurt Cobain's suicide and Ellen DeGeneres' "Coming Out" episode. Both Cobain and Jackson made it to the semifinals before a "late surge by Apple fans edged them out." Never underestimate the power of fanboys.

So what do you think? Do you agree that the cell phone was robbed of its deserved place on the list? And tell me about any other tech that you think Entertainment Weekly overlooked.

Recent posts from Crave
This week in Crave-land
Crave: There's a Storm a-brewing
Even more Samsung phones clear the FCC
Ubiquitous Netbooks, a cheap Acer, and WiMax cometh: The week in laptops
Gamers, prepare to join the 'Secret Service'
Add a Comment (Log in or register) 13 comments
by mjbarak July 1, 2008 12:40 PM PDT
No question the cell phone belongs on the list. Stadium Multiplex seating? Who cares. Satellite radio? Not exactly worthy of top ten. I'm sure that WHERE the cell phone belongs in the top ten would be the subject of huge debate, but the fact that it is missing from that list is just absurd.
Reply to this comment
by thisislovell July 1, 2008 2:24 PM PDT
The only logical reason for the cell phone not to be included is if it existed before 1983 (which I'm not sure about). Even if it did, the proliferation of cell phones in the past 25 years is way too much to be completely ignored.
Reply to this comment
by 7aji88 July 1, 2008 5:19 PM PDT
Tivo??? Satellite radio stations??? I'm pretty sure that we still use FM because I don't want to pay money to listen to radio. I think cell phone should be #2 and if you take Tivo away and place "Napster ??" in its place then the list would make more sense.. maybe?? :(
Reply to this comment
by calculatorwatch July 2, 2008 10:49 AM PDT
Yeah that's crazy. I think people (like the writers of the magazine) just take cell phones for granted because they're such a regular part of our lives. But try going a week or so without one and you realize how much of a difference they've made.

I don't see how dvd player belongs at the top of the list since, at least as far as pop culture goes, it's hardly different than watching stuff on vhs.
Reply to this comment
by athensa July 2, 2008 4:09 PM PDT
Mobile phones have been around for many years, and have just kind of evolved into the ubiquitous item they are today. All the other items were basically the first of their kind. Don't forget that the DVD player not only made movies more portable, but people BOUGHT DVDs rather than rent them, since the rental windows of VHS didn't exist for DVD. It completely changed the Hollywood money making system. Personally, I'd say Napster/ iTunes should be #1, since they ushered in the realm of digital media.
Reply to this comment
by shredderc July 2, 2008 9:31 PM PDT
Absolutely absurd. Without a doubt, they should be #1. Maxwell Smart's shoe phone doesn't mean cellular existed before 1983. We can live without most of the items on this list, but we can't live without cell phones because they've displaced pay phones. Even if I found one, it would be difficult to pay, because I wouldn't have a quarter in my pocket. Other technology (ATM's, automated toll systems) has wiped out the need for pocket change.
Reply to this comment
by tlbrewer5 July 4, 2008 7:48 PM PDT
first off NAPSTER??? Multiplex seating and no CELL PHONE???????

that is completely absurd. Maybe its such an everyday item that it slipped everyones mind.
Reply to this comment
by athensa July 5, 2008 7:02 AM PDT
Again, all the items on the list DIDN'T EXIST before 1983. Mobile phones, in whatever primitive form they were, did.
Reply to this comment
by blabtech July 5, 2008 9:40 AM PDT
Maybe they should run the top tech thing again and see the new results..

http://blabtech.blogspot.com
Reply to this comment
by bob0444 July 5, 2008 9:41 AM PDT
Once again we see a wonderful article written with the total lack of research on what they are writing the article on. The cell phone was marketed in Japan in by NTT in 1978 and by 1983 they were in fairly wide use through Motorola in the USA. Therefore they couldn't include the cell phone in there grouping. They might have decided to add the electronic PDA in name your favorite flavor (blackberry, Palm Pilot, Apple Newton), or perhaps something that is useful like the TomTom. What I am suprised is that no one mentioned the Hybrid electric car or flat panel (LCD or Plasma) TVs that have been around for nearly 100 years but only in the last 10-12 years have been available to consumers.
Reply to this comment View reply
by Composer_1777 July 5, 2008 5:20 PM PDT
Cell phones Belong at #1 no questions asked. I pod is nothing compared to Thriller, wow that is unfathomable.
Reply to this comment
by isaacszy July 6, 2008 10:53 AM PDT
My best guess is that it didn't occur to the 22-year-old intern who compiled the story that cell phones haven't ALWAYS been with us. Maybe they assume that these are just "phones" invented in the 19th century by A.G. Bell.... ;)
Reply to this comment
Powered by Jive Software
advertisement

About Crave

The name says it all. Crave is our blog about gorgeous gadgets and other crushworthy stuff. If you would like to contact Crave with a tip or comment, please write to: crave@cnet.com

Add this feed to your online news reader

Crave topics

advertisement

Inside CNET News

Scroll Left Scroll Right