January 23, 2008 8:08 AM PST

Get an HP dual-core notebook for $465

(Credit: eCost)

Call me crazy, but I don't understand why anyone would buy the much-ballyhooed Asus Eee PC for $399 when they could get a full-fledged notebook for just a few bucks more. Case in point: eCost has the HP Presario F579WM for $465. Granted, it's an HP-recertified model, one that weighs three times as much as the Asus, but it's also much, much better equipped for everyday computing.

In addition to its dual-core AMD Athlon processor, the 6.6-pound Presario comes with 1GB of RAM, a 120GB hard drive, a super-multi-DVD burner, and a 15.4-inch screen. In short, it's a solid entry-level notebook, one that should easily satisfy users with basic needs. It even has discrete graphics in the form of an Nvidia GeForce Go 6150 processor, meaning games aren't out of the question.

The notebook includes a 90-day warranty. You can find complete specs here.

Originally posted at The Cheapskate
A technology writer for over 15 years, Rick Broida is a regular contributor to CNET and the author of over a dozen books, including "How to Do Everything with Your Palm Powered Handheld." He writes The Cheapskate for the CNET Blog Network, and is not an employee of CNET. Disclosure.
Recent posts from Crave
Yelle, 'Je Veux Te Voir': Free MP3 of the Day
Looking back, looking ahead: The week in laptops
Attention back-to-school shoppers: Find your laptop reviews here
Gear4 shrinks 'BlackBox' speaker to travel size
Review: 2009 Acura TSX
Add a Comment (Log in or register) 7 comments (Page 1 of 1)
Odd comparison??
by brantroz January 23, 2008 9:59 AM PST
I get that the main comparison here is Cost of the HP vs the Eee, and features delivered at that price-point... But on the other hand, isn't this is like comparing a SmartCar to a Dumptruck??? I think the point of the Eee is its ultra-portability and its super-minimalist design. This HP in the link (though a great price) is a MONSTER... even larger than the Compaq nc6400 which I carry around for work (and which breaks my back during commutes.) I agree that you get more "bang for the buck" with something like an HP desktop replacement (which this pretty much is)... but the reasonable premium you pay for ultra portability in something like the Eee is, I believe, targeting a different customer demographic. Those who love a concept like the Eee would prefer it over the duel-core HP because they likely already have a heavy-use desktop/laptop at home. They're shopping for an "on the go" communications/surfing/entertainment device for lightweight online use. Who cares if it won't play WOW if you can get online with it anywhere and almost forget it is in your bag? -B
Reply to this comment
...discrete graphics?
by scythie January 24, 2008 6:06 AM PST
Uhm, the nVidia GeForce Go 6150 IS NOT a discrete GPU. It's an integrated graphics card. The Intel X3100 GMA isn't the only integrated graphics option around, you know. For AMD laptops, there are a bunch of choices for integrated graphics, including the GF Go 6150, 7150, and the ATI Xpress 1250.
Reply to this comment
Never buy refurbished!
by dfichtner January 24, 2008 1:43 PM PST
Never buy a refurbished computer. I've bought two in the past, and in both instances, the true problem was not fixed. Nothing like having to replace your hard drive and go through an entirely new windows installation (after trying to prove it to some guy from India for 3 hours) less than a week after you've bought the thing. The 2nd computer would just randomly shut off after several minutes. Try to prove that one to an online technician! In the end, I finally got it replaced, but it wasn't worth the hassle to save $100 over buying new. Never buy refurbished. I think there should be a law that all refurbished good should include an explanation of what was wrong and what was/wasn't done to correct it.
Reply to this comment
Not looking back
by FunEee January 24, 2008 2:11 PM PST
I used to have a Compaq F579WM and I was happy to trade it away for an Asus Eee 8g. I was tired of lugging around that 15inch note book, with it's case and power brick. My Eee fits in my book bag and my dufflebage for work. Something the Compaq could never do.
Reply to this comment
Better yet...
by dizzyastad January 24, 2008 3:20 PM PST
buy a desktop for $200, an old CRT for $10, a car battery for $20, and a pair of suspenders for $5. Strap everything to your back with the suspenders and BAM, for only $235 you've got even more bang for your buck. Jokes aside, this blog is comparing Apples with Panzer Tanks.
Reply to this comment
"eee" is the only Portable Computer
by jabailo January 25, 2008 9:47 AM PST
The reason that people buy the eee is that it is truly portable as in: (a) can be easily carried (b) can run for a reasonable amount of time without being tethered to a power outlet. No other "notebook" meets these criteria. The standard laptop, which has now come down to earthly prices, is still the wrong choice for most people who will still find a really good desktop machine with a large lcd monitor situtated at an ergnometric desk and chair to be the idea computing environment. Also, the parts and ease of configuration of a desktop are far more approachable than in a laptop.
Reply to this comment
Non exactly apples to oranges, but
by mishani January 25, 2008 8:36 PM PST
The Asus is compact and nice, but it's more a large PDA than a laptop - there is no excuse these days for a laptop with a 7" screen and a 4Gb drive :). It has excellent potential - too bad Asus decided to strip it to the minimum to keep the price down. It would have been so much more useful with a 10" screen (or whatever size fits in this frame) and a real hard drive for an extra $200 or so.
Reply to this comment
Powered by Jive Software
advertisement

About Crave

The name says it all. Crave is our blog about gorgeous gadgets and other crushworthy stuff. If you would like to contact Crave with a tip or comment, please write to: crave@cnet.com

I Crave

advertisement
Click Here.
Crave home

Crave

Switch background color:
A Blog from CNET

A Blog from CNET

Visit other CNET Networks sites: