March 21, 2007 3:46 PM PDT

Apple TV: First impressions

UPDATE: Full review (with hands-on video) now available.

Today we got our first in-person look at the Apple TV since its unveiling back in September of 2006. Company representatives were showing it off at a Manhattan hotel suite and gave us a loaner to do our own hands-on testing. While we conduct a full review, here's our first impression--and a video of our own Rich DeMuro diving into the box for the first time.

The Apple TV is a bigger, stationery-networked iPod that you hook up to your TV, and its degree of desirability is directly proportional to how much iTunes is the center of your digital media universe. If you've got all your music in iTunes and you frequently purchase TV shows and movies from Apple's service, Apple TV is enticing indeed. It can automatically sync with one iTunes library but, instead of requiring the use of an iPod, it's done automatically via your home network. You can also stream music, video, and podcasts directly from up to five networked computers (Windows PCs and Macs). Streaming from guest computers--say, a friend's laptop that has the latest episode of 24 or Lost--is as easy as a couple of keystrokes.

Apple TV gets big points for ease of setup, its superslick on-screen interface, and its impressive features--specifically, supporting up to 720p HD video output and superfast 802.11n wireless networking. But the flip side of that HD support is that it's at the expense of older television sets--Apple TV lacks the standard outputs for connecting to anything without a component (480p) or HDMI output. And while many media streamers don't have any built-in storage at all, it's disappointing that the Apple TV's internal hard drive is limited to only 40GB--for those keeping score at home, that's merely half the size of the most capacious iPod now on the market.

Those nitpicks notwithstanding, the Apple TV is pretty much the only network entertainment device available that will play content (music, movies, and TV shows) purchased from the iTunes Store. But that iTunes compatibility is also something of an Achilles' heel, because it means that you're responsible for getting your digital video files transcoded into an iTunes-friendly format (essentially, MPEG4/H.264). Yes, QuickTime Pro ($30), iMovie, and plenty of third-party programs can do just that, but it can be a time-consuming manual process. By contrast, many competing devices can stream a variety of other file formats--WMV, AVI, DivX, and the like--without the need for conversions (but they can't stream the files you purchased from the iTunes Store).

Of course, each of those pluses and minuses are totally subjective. At this early stage, the fact that Apple TV brings iPod-like convenience and ease of use to the network-streaming media market is really its trump card. Digital media pack rats with multi-gigabyte, multi-codec video collections will want to look elsewhere--or begin the mother of all QuickTime transcoding sessions--but anyone looking to enjoy their iTunes content in the comfort of their living room may well find the Apple TV to be their favorite gadget since the iPod.

Recent posts from Crave
Barenaked Ladies, '7, 8, 9': Free MP3 of the Day
The Cool Kids, 'That'll Work': Free MP3 of the Day
Photos: On the ground and in the air at Farnborough Air Show
TransferJet: Plug and play, minus the plug
Accessories for the iPod Touch
Add a Comment (Log in or register) 48 comments (Page 1 of 4)
Apple As Usual
by colmaboy March 21, 2007 5:29 PM PDT
Overpriced goods with less than stellar goods under the hood. Typical Apple.
Reply to this comment
Apple As Usual
by colmaboy March 21, 2007 5:29 PM PDT
Overpriced goods with less than stellar goods under the hood. Typical Apple.
Reply to this comment
Luddites = MacLuddites
by Alevino March 21, 2007 5:39 PM PDT
They are the neo-luddites. Everything out A...e is bad!!!
Pay for your religion...
Pray for your illusion...
Cry for you clan!!!

Apple TV... plea tv...
Reply to this comment
Luddites = MacLuddites
by Alevino March 21, 2007 5:39 PM PDT
They are the neo-luddites. Everything out A...e is bad!!!
Pay for your religion...
Pray for your illusion...
Cry for you clan!!!

Apple TV... plea tv...
Reply to this comment
oh my god!!!
by freakyrandy March 21, 2007 7:02 PM PDT
i wished i had known that "out of the box" really meant OUT OF THE BOX.

thank god i watched. now i know how to get the damn thing out of the box. you just need a carpet cutter to get the shrink wrap off.

thank you so much for the informative video.

you're the guy who reads the directions on the side of the pop-tart box, aren't you?
Reply to this comment
oh my god!!!
by freakyrandy March 21, 2007 7:02 PM PDT
i wished i had known that "out of the box" really meant OUT OF THE BOX.

thank god i watched. now i know how to get the damn thing out of the box. you just need a carpet cutter to get the shrink wrap off.

thank you so much for the informative video.

you're the guy who reads the directions on the side of the pop-tart box, aren't you?
Reply to this comment
Apple is all good, but....
by euspos March 21, 2007 7:29 PM PDT
iTunes interfacing and QuickTime is all good, but what about what people REALLY are looking for;
- capability to play DVD files (.ifo and .vob)
- bigger hard drive
- capability to direct connect to a NAS device
- S-video output
- photo/picture browser
- web browsing

+ of course the iTunes music capabilities (for playing mp3s, but likely all good there)

Was anticipating the appleTV after its first announcement in January, but so far it looks like AirLink Tech's MediaGate products offer better "all-around" capabilities (+annoying quirks and some instability).

Dispite the technical drawbacks, I am sure that appleTV will be a commercial success due to its "microclimate" where everything "Apple" works fine together, as long as you accept its limitations. It will quickly enter into the livingrooms of families that do not want to fiddle with their tech equipment in order to get the most out of it. They just want it to work.

For the rest of us, that know stuff actually can do BETTER, the Koreans are still developing TRUE "media streamers", and there are a number of xBox mods available. Possibly even Wii mods, but have not ventured there yet.
Reply to this comment
Apple is all good, but....
by euspos March 21, 2007 7:29 PM PDT
iTunes interfacing and QuickTime is all good, but what about what people REALLY are looking for;
- capability to play DVD files (.ifo and .vob)
- bigger hard drive
- capability to direct connect to a NAS device
- S-video output
- photo/picture browser
- web browsing

+ of course the iTunes music capabilities (for playing mp3s, but likely all good there)

Was anticipating the appleTV after its first announcement in January, but so far it looks like AirLink Tech's MediaGate products offer better "all-around" capabilities (+annoying quirks and some instability).

Dispite the technical drawbacks, I am sure that appleTV will be a commercial success due to its "microclimate" where everything "Apple" works fine together, as long as you accept its limitations. It will quickly enter into the livingrooms of families that do not want to fiddle with their tech equipment in order to get the most out of it. They just want it to work.

For the rest of us, that know stuff actually can do BETTER, the Koreans are still developing TRUE "media streamers", and there are a number of xBox mods available. Possibly even Wii mods, but have not ventured there yet.
Reply to this comment
Are you an idiot? or do you think we are?
by sbee March 21, 2007 8:52 PM PDT
'First impressions' implies a dimwit figuring out how to open a shrink-wrapped box? CNET content has fallen to such depths? Who is the target audience for this absorbing video and how dumb do you think they are?

I really should go and spread my new found knowledge of box opening and prying components out of the box to the world. CNET, learn to NOT put up dumb content till you actually manage a review. Dear God!
Reply to this comment View reply
Are you an idiot? or do you think we are?
by sbee March 21, 2007 8:52 PM PDT
'First impressions' implies a dimwit figuring out how to open a shrink-wrapped box? CNET content has fallen to such depths? Who is the target audience for this absorbing video and how dumb do you think they are?

I really should go and spread my new found knowledge of box opening and prying components out of the box to the world. CNET, learn to NOT put up dumb content till you actually manage a review. Dear God!
Reply to this comment View reply
1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Next 10 Comments >>
Powered by Jive Software
advertisement

About Crave

The name says it all. Crave is our blog about gorgeous gadgets and other crushworthy stuff. If you would like to contact Crave with a tip or comment, please write to: crave@cnet.com

I Crave

advertisement
Crave home

Crave

Switch background color:
A Blog from CNET

A Blog from CNET

Visit other CNET Networks sites: